A Good Team Player

Kristin joined as supervisor of Steven’s department. Steven is assistant department manager and thinks that some of his co-workers got promoted and over time opportunities just because they were liked better and he told Kristin that changing that will make it the department better. Kristin called Steven next morning and asked for the names who are not team players and Steve was referring to.

The relevant facts of the case –

Steven joined the accounts payable section in a major industrial firm after graduating from college, and he is currently the Assistant department manager. Steven is comfortable in his job and thought he knew all the ins and outs of the organization.

Kristin is the newly appointed supervisor, with a proven talent to improve the efficiency of operations. Kristin was in a similar position in a different subsidiary. Kristin was meeting each employee and asking for their opinions to improve the working place.

When Kristin asked Steven about his opinion, Steven shared his thought people got promotion and overtime work opportunities based on who liked them and not based on their merit. Kristin assured Steven that she would look into that.

Kristin wanted to see Steven the next morning and asked him to tell her the people was referring to, otherwise, Kristin would consider Steven to be not a team player.

Ethical issues including the extent of Steven’s responsibility to take action

Steven thought that some people at work are getting promotion and over time just because they are liked better. When Kristin asked Steven for the names of who Steven was referring to, according to Kristin she would not tolerate the team members who are not team players, and if Steven could not provide the names then she would consider Steven is not a team player.

            Considering Steven was honest and truthful, Steven’s problem is to give the names of his co-workers who he has known for a long time to Kristin, who is his supervisor for just 1 day. Probably Steven was not very happy that he did not get overtimes or promotions, and he thought it was not a level playing field, so he wanted to have a better chance at those going forward. So essentially, it was Steve’s perception and now Steve was being asked for evidence. If Steve gives names to Kristin, then it is guaranteed that Steve will not have a good working relationship with coworkers, and if Steve does not give any name, Steve might lose job eventually.  

            Since I made an initial assumption that Steve is an honest person, I would think Steve should go ahead tell the names who he thinks were less deserving. Maybe he would turn out to be right or he will get an explanation what they did to deserve what they got and what Steve should do going forward.

Various stakeholders, and what is at stake for each one.

Of course, Steve is a stakeholder – he needs to show Kristin that he was true, or he might lose reputation and job.

            Kristin is the next stakeholder, she wants to make the workplace efficient.

            Other employees are also stakeholders, Steve might prove some of them are not team players and that will not be good for them.

Alternatives and ethics of each alternative.  

            The first alternative Steve has is to apologize and admit that he was wrong. But that will not work out so well, as he will be considered as not a team player and probably he might lose his job for lying.

            The other option is, to be honest, and provide Kristin the full information of what Steve noticed regarding not so deserving candidates getting promoted and getting overtime. That way, with all the details Kristin, will see the full picture and as she wishes to do, increase efficiency, she might be able to weed out undeserving employees and replace them with deserving ones. From a utilitarian perspective, the 2nd option is a better one. As the whole workplace will be efficient in the long run, in the short run Kristin will get what she wants from Steve. Steve will prove his point to Kristin. But those employees who actually benefitted from the bureaucracy will lose their perks. That is a good thing for the organization in the long run.

Practical constraints

The practical constraint is taking the name of coworkers in this situation while working with them, it will dampen the working relationship. According to Kathy Caprino, “When your emotions are spinning out of control about a colleague, and you feel anger, hurt, resentment and other highly-charged emotions, you need to settle down before you communicate to anyone about the situation.  Further, think hard about backstabbing at all.  If you do it, you’ll simply project an image of yourself that you’re untrustworthy, and someone who doesn’t have the courage and strength to handle things in a positive, direct way with the individuals involved.” And moreover, since Kristin does not have much background on anyone or people before that how would Steve prove that he is right and those employees got a promotion just because they were liked and they did not deserve the overtimes or promotions

How should Steven respond?

            Steve should provide the name of his coworkers who got promotions and overtimes because they were liked and not deserved. Once he gives the names, he will have to provide reasons why they did not deserve the promotion. Because there could be a reason that they were deserving and that is why they were liked. But as Dave Kerpen says “Always tell the truth to your boss, and never tell a lie.

Lies are too risky – not only to your relationship with your boss but to your relationship with yourself.” Steve has no way to back down, so he should say what he thinks and whoever is involved.


Caprino, K ( July,2012). The Top 10 Work Situations Where Honesty Is Not the Best Policy. Retrieved from https://www.forbes.com/sites/kathycaprino/2012/07/31/the-top-10-work-situations-where-honesty-is-not-the-best-policy/#5042c336123a

Kerpen, D ( Sept,2013). 17 Things You Should Never Say to Your Boss. Retrieved from https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/20130923134035-15077789-17-things-you-should-never-say-to-your-boss/

Author: pachubabu

I love trying different cuisine, hiking, travelling and blogging about personal finance ,investing & health/fitness

162 thoughts on “A Good Team Player”

  1. Jordan 12 Gym Redhttp://www.jordan12gymred.us.com/
    nike factory outlet store onlinehttp://www.nikefactoryoutletstoreonline.com/
    Nike Outlet satorehttp://www.nikefactoryoutletstoreonline.us/
    Nike Storehttp://www.nikestores.us.com/
    retro jordan 33http://www.jordan33.us/
    cheap custom nfl jerseyshttp://www.customnfljerseys.us/
    air jordan 11 concordhttp://www.jordan11concord.us.com/
    Jordan 12 Gym Redhttp://www.jordan12gymred.us/
    Jordan 12 Gym Red 2018http://www.redjordan12.us/
    Yeezy Supplyhttp://www.yeezysupply.us.com/
    Yeezy Boost 350http://www.yeezy-shoes.us.com/
    Yeezy Boost 350 V2http://www.yeezy-boost350.com/
    Yeezy Boost 350http://www.yeezyboost350.us.com/
    Yeezy Boost 350 V2 Blue Tinthttp://www.yeezybluetint.com/
    Adidas Yeezy 500http://www.yeezy500utilityblack.com/
    Yeezy 500http://www.yeezy500utilityblack.us/
    Nike Air VaporMaxhttp://www.vapor-max.org.uk/
    Salomon UKhttp://www.salomon-shoes.org.uk/
    Salomon Shoeshttp://www.salomons.me.uk/
    Salomon UKhttp://www.salomonspeedcross4.org.uk/
    Off White Jordanhttp://www.offwhitejordan1.com/
    Nike VaporMaxhttp://www.nikevapormax.org.uk/
    Nike React Element 87http://www.nikereactelement87.us.com/
    Nike Element 87http://www.nikereactelement87.us/
    Nike Plushttp://www.nikeplus.us/
    Nike Outlet Storehttp://www.nike–outlet.us/
    Nike Outlet Storehttp://www.nikeoutletstoreonlineshopping.us/
    Nike Outlet Storehttp://www.nikeoutletonlineshopping.us/
    Cheap Nike NBA Jerseyshttp://www.nikenbajerseys.us/
    Air Max Nikehttp://www.nikeairmax.us/
    Air Max Nikehttp://www.max2017.us/
    Air Jordan Shoeshttp://www.jordan-com.com/
    Jordan 11 Concordhttp://www.jordan11-concord.com/
    Cheap Yeezy Boosthttp://www.cs7boots1.com/
    Wholesale Cheap NBA Jerseyshttp://www.cheapnba-jerseys.us/
    Birkenstock Sandalshttp://www.birkenstocksandalsuk.me.uk/
    NBA Jerseyshttp://www.basketball-jersey.us/
    Balenciaga UKhttp://www.birkenstocks.me.uk/
    Balenciaga UKhttp://www.balenciagatrainers.org.uk/
    Nike Air Max 270http://www.airmax270.org.uk/
    Yeezy Shoeshttp://www.adidasyeezyshoes.org.uk/
    Yeezy Shoeshttp://www.adidasyeezyshoes.org.uk/

  2. Nice read, I just passed this onto a friend who was doing some research on that. And he just bought me lunch because I found it for him smile Therefore let me rephrase that: Thank you for lunch! “Not only is the universe stranger than we imagine, it is stranger than we can imagine.” by Sir Arthur Eddington.

  3. I wish to show my thanks to this writer for bailing me out of this type of problem. After scouting through the the net and coming across suggestions that were not powerful, I assumed my entire life was done. Being alive without the approaches to the problems you’ve sorted out all through this short post is a crucial case, as well as the kind which could have badly affected my entire career if I hadn’t discovered the website. Your personal capability and kindness in taking care of a lot of stuff was very useful. I don’t know what I would’ve done if I hadn’t come upon such a solution like this. I’m able to at this point relish my future. Thanks a lot very much for your impressive and amazing help. I won’t be reluctant to endorse your web sites to anybody who should have assistance about this subject.

  4. I wanted to put you this very small note in order to give thanks yet again over the nice concepts you have discussed in this article. This has been so shockingly open-handed of people like you to provide publicly just what a few people could have distributed for an electronic book to earn some cash for their own end, mostly since you might well have tried it if you considered necessary. These smart ideas as well served to be a easy way to recognize that other people have the same dreams similar to mine to figure out great deal more in terms of this condition. I am certain there are lots of more pleasant times up front for individuals who scan your blog post.

  5. I have to convey my love for your kind-heartedness giving support to individuals that have the need for guidance on that question. Your real commitment to getting the solution all over became extremely functional and has regularly enabled somebody like me to arrive at their ambitions. Your amazing helpful report can mean a whole lot to me and much more to my office colleagues. Many thanks; from all of us.

  6. Thank you a lot for providing individuals with a very marvellous possiblity to read from this website. It is usually so useful and as well , stuffed with fun for me personally and my office mates to search your website on the least three times every week to read through the latest tips you have. Not to mention, we are at all times happy with all the eye-popping tips you give. Selected 1 facts in this post are rather the most beneficial I’ve ever had.

Comments are closed.